8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

1/292

TTwwccuu}}hh WWllvv RRffcciilluullrrffcchh`

JJppnnttppii 88,,44228822

GGCCIILLUULLGGCC@@HHJJHHIICC]]CCEEUUCCUULLEECCHHII..RRLLIICC]]CCEE**

HHDDLLTTMMTTCCHHEE]]PPHHII@@

JJppnntt `mmcc}}hh}} mm`

MMcchhjjhh MM`eehhccEEllttccjjhh NNhh}}`cc

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

2/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 4

CUUJ 4822.2273Elrstcaf} ]lh} mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}`

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

3/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 5

T`mhech Wlv Rfcilulrfch`T`mhe}ltc `gcMtm* Ultcj Eihpmcp NHTCEH) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Ulrfch.Hj}crlicu) Jcuh &Gthjh#Mt* Eltcjh NH]@C) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Urctp Fht`}) Dpept`}c &Tlnjch#

N`ndtc m` ljlht`Rtlg* mt* Clj ELRL@TP) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Dhd`.Dlishc) Eipo.Jhrleh &Tlnjch#

Rtlg* mt* O`hj.Gthjlcu IHWCAJ@) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Ulrfch.Hj}crlicu) Jcuh &Gthjh#Rtlg* mt* O`hj ATLJMCJ) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h mcj Nlj}t`hi &Ehjhmh#Rtlg* mt* Eihpm` TLNHJL) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Rhtcu Ultdljj`.Rhtcu CW &Gthjh#Mt* Ecrtchj WIEHJ) uetcc}lt c gcilulg) Rt``mcj}` hi Ulec`}cc ]cj`tcilt Pjcw`tuc}htc mcjTlnjchRtlg* mt* Wihmcnct ]CUNJ@HJP) M`rht}n`j} lg Alw`tjn`j} hjm Rlic}ceu) Pjcw`tuc}s lgNhtsihjm &PUH#

Elnc}`} }ccjcgce c m` i`e}ptMt* Cic` RCJ]@H) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Urctp Fht`}) Dpept`}c &Tlnjch#Mtm* Jceli`}h U_HDL) Pjcw`tuc} Opi`u W`tj`) Hnc`ju &Gthjh#Mtm* Mchjh M@EH) Elajc}cw` Uec`je` E`j}`t) Hnu}`tmhn &Lihjmh#Mt* Ahdtc`i GPTNP_HEFC) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h mcj Wc`jh &Hpu}tch#Mt* Ataltc O@HJ) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Ulrfch.Hj}crlicu &Gthjh#Mt* Sw`u NHS_HPM) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h mcj Qprr`t}hi &A`tnhjch#Mtm* Usiwhcj EHNCII@TC) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Rhpi Whits . Nlj}r`iic`t CCC &Gthjh#

Elnc}`}pi m` t`mhec`Mtm* Thipeh NLEHJ) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Rhtcu @u} &Gthjh#

Mt* U`tacp DIHJ) Cju}c}p}pi m` Gcilulgc` c Rucflilac` hi Hehm`nc`c Tlnj`Mt* Nhamhi`jh MPNC]THJH) Pjcw`tuc}h}`h m` U}h} mcj Rc}`}c) Ghepi}h}`h m` }ccj` hi`@mpehc`cMt* Fltch.Wce`jcp RH]THUEP) Pjcw tuc}h}`h Urctp Fht`}) Dpept`}c

Elnc}`}pi m` }thmpe`t`Ucnljh.Ncfh`ih CIC@Etcu}cjh Rh}tcech AF@LTAF@

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

4/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` =

Ctcjh Etcu}cjh AICUHEtcu}cjh Icwch WHUCI@UEP

Ncfh`ih R@]TCEHHjh.Nhtch DHM@H]`ljh DLA]@HJ

U`mcp c t`mhec`?N* Ultcj NHTCEH) 44) Cnrhuu` m`u Ecahi`u) @j}t` @) 27=22) Ehjj`u) Gthje`

Hmt`u m` nhci?elj}he}Brfcilulrfcehi.t`wc`q*cjgl ]`i`glj?2255786155643R`tclmcec}h}`?T`wcu}h Wlv Rfcilulrfch`hrht` dchjphi) pj`ltc ep hmhlupi pjpc jpnt ur`echi*

Hi}` cjgltnhcc?T`wcu} h Rtlc`e}pipc epi}pthi Wlv Rfcilulrfch`

Hp}ltcc upj} tpahc h ru}th elrcc hi` nhjpuetcu`ilt) j}tpe} he`u}`h jp u` t`}ptj`hz*

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

5/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 0

Eprtcju

Epwj} jhcj}` *************************************************************************************************** 6

Cj}`twcptcHja`ih DL]@_Cic` RTWPNcte`h GILJ]H

MLUHT ? Gcilulgc` hjhic}ce c ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`Cucmlth U}lohjlwceQf`j Cu He}clj Cj}`j}cljhi

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

6/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 7

T`hicunpi ipc Ncte`h Giltchj* Hur`e}`i` lj}lilace`*********************************************** 76Uhefh Dlpta`lcu.Actljm`Dhz`i` jh}pthi` hi` nlj`m`c********************************************************************************* 60Giltchj Elwh

I` u}h}p} cj}`j}cljj`i mpj` he}clj mr`jm.ci m` uh whi`pt nlthi`< Pj` jcan` `jelt` tulpmt`* ******************************************************************************************************** 822I`ljhtm Tpup

Xp`u}.e` xp` i` ]the}h}pu< Xp`u}clj? ih ilacxp` metc}.`ii` i` nljm`

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

7/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 1

Cjgip`jh cm`cilt ipc C* Khj} c A* Q* Gt* F`a`i j `u}`}ceh tlnj`hue************** 422

WHTCH

Eihpm` TlnhjlLtczlj}pi g`jln`jlilac`c*********************************************************************************** 423Ucnljh RhuepIh eflu` `j}t` A`ihuu`jf`c} `} A`u}`ii**************************************************************** 40=Nmicj LjpG`jln`jpi el}cmchjc}cc; rtlwleht`h `efcicdtpipc f`tn`j`p}ce***************************** 413Cjmcehcc r`j}tp hp}ltcc ht}celi`ilt ************************************************************** 432Cjmceh}clju hpv hp}`ptu ******************************************************************************** 432

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

8/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 6

Epwj} jhcj}`)

Hw`n dpeptch m` h w rt`z`j}h rtcnpi jpnt hi t`wcu}`c Wlv Rfcilulrfch`m`mceh} gcilulgc`c hjhic}ce`* Pjpi mcj}t` nl}cw`i` e`i` nhc cnrlt}hj}` r`j}tphe`hu}h ` e `i `u}` t`zpi}h}pi `glt}pipc elnpj m` h t`pjc ipettci` pjlt }hi`j}hchp}ltc tlnjc c u}tcjc) j uelrpi m` h rtlnlwh hr}c}pmcjci` hehm`nce` j he`u}mln`jcp*

Ep }lh}` e n`mcpi hehm`nce hi gcilulgc`c tlnj`}c `u}` glht}`elnr`}c}cw) j `v}`tclt u` epjlh}` rt`h rpcj j rtcwcjh }`jmcj`ilt he}phi` mcjgcilulgch tlnj`hue* M` he``h) j`.hn ajmc} u et`n lehzch eh pjcc mcj}t` e`c

nhc dpjc n`ndtc hc elnpjc}cc hehm`nce` tlnj`}c u.c rtld`z`elnr`}`jh* Hn eljucm`th} m` epwccj e ` }cnrpi c e u` ghe` ucnc} j`wlchpjpc gltpn j eht` u gc` hpzc}` wleci` mcj he`u} mln`jcp gcilulgce*

Rpdiceh} upd hpurcecci` Ulec`}cc Tlnj` m` Gcilulgc` Hjhic}ce) wlipnpihe`u}h) cj}c}pih} Gcilulgc` hjhic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`) `u}` l w`tucpj` h t`wcu}`ccj}`tjhcljhi` dchjphi`) h}`j} t`wczpc}) mltcjm h `vrtcnh pj urctc} hehm`nce c h}t`zc cj}`t`upi pjpc rpdice e} nhc ihta* Ec}c}ltcc ipc wlt j}ijc hp}ltc ur`echiczhc)m` ltcacj` tlnj) `jai`z uhp gthje`z) ju wlipnpi u` hmt`u`hz c lhn`jcilt

m` }ccj c n`mcpipc pjcw`tuc}ht mcj npi}` hi}` mln`jcc* ]`v}`i` hrtp}` j he`u} jpnt }th}`hz }`lt`}ce j rtcnpi tjm }`n`gcilulgce` dcj`epjluep}`) m` ih elj`vcpj`h mcj}t` gcilulgch ncjcc c m`uelr`tctci`he}phi` mcj }ccj`i` j`ptljhi`) rj ih dhzh elje`r}phi h `eljlnc`c) uhp efchtih jh}pth juc h thcpjcc* j he`u} u`ju) gcilulgch hjhic}ce rlh}` gc rtcwc} c ehcjeipzjm updc`e}` e` wcz`hz lj}lilach) `rcu}`nlilach) n`}hgczceh c gcilulgchrlic}ce* E``h e` `vcu} j }lh}` he`u}` hdltmtc c ehthe}`tcz`hz }crpi he`u}h m`rthe}ce gcilulgce t`zcm j rt`g`tcjh r`j}tp eihtc}h}` c r`j}tp l dhz ilace h

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

9/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 3

mcueptupipc &w`zc eljucu}`jh htapn`j}`ilt#*

Gt hi}` hmhluptc) mltcn u j` `vrtcnn jej}ht`h c t`epjl}cjhgh m` hp}ltc r`j}tp elj}tcdpcci` ilt `ve`i`j}`) rt`epn c gh m` n`ndtcceltrpipc t`mhecljhi r`j}tp h gc gep} rlucdci he`u} rtlc`e} cjec}hj}) hwjmur`thjh e `i t`rt`zcj} mlht pj je`rp}*

Hc mpnj`hwlhu}t ep ucje`tc}h}`)@mc}ltcc*

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

10/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 82

CJ]@TWCPTC M@ GCILULGC@ HJHIC]CE?

HJA@IH DL]@_CIC@ RTWP

NCTE@H GILJ]H

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

11/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 88

j}t`dtcilt t`mhec`c jlhu}t`) gltnpih}` ep eljeptupi mlnjpipc i`e}lt pjcw*mt* Mthal Dap) Ghepi}h}`h m` Optjhicun) Elnpjceht` c T`ihcc Rpdice`)Pjcw`tuc}h}`h Urctp Fht`}) hp hwp} hnhdcic}h}`h u turpjm) j ltmcj`)ptn}ltcc ur`echic}c) etlth t`mhech jlhu}t i` npipn`}`?

C* Hja`ih Dl}`z) e`te`}}lt }ccjcgce rtcjecrhi C) `gh eli`e}cwpipc m`@rcu}`nlilac` c Gcilulgch }ccj`c ih Cju}c}p}pi m` Gcilulgc` c Rucflilac`

E* Tmpi`uep.Nl}tp hi Hehm`nc`c Tlnj`;CC* Cic` Rtwp) rtlg`ult pjcw`tuc}ht mle}lt) Ghepi}h}`h m` Gcilulgc` hPjcw`tuc}cc Dpept`}c) n`ndtp elt`urljm`j} hi Hehm`nc`c Tlnj`*

CCC* Ncte`h Gilj}h) rtlg`ult pjcw`tuc}ht mle}lt) Ghepi}h}`h m` Gcilulgc`h Pjcw`tuc}cc Dpept`}c) n`ndtp elt`urljm`j} hi Hehm`nc`c Tlnj`*

C*

Mthal Dap? 8* j rt`z`j}) ucj}hanh gcilulgc` hjhic}ce u`t`g`t ih hp}ltc c elje`rcc mcj}t` e`i` nhc mcw`tu`) hrhtcjjm pjltmcuecricj` gcilulgce` mcg`tc}`* Et`m`c e) j rlgcmh he`u}`c mcw`tuc}c)`vcu} l n`}lm uhp pj u`} m` }`z` ur`ecgce` he`u}`c }thmccc

8/8/2019 Vox Philosophiae, Filosofie analitic i social-politic. Abordri actuale

12/292

Gcilulgc` hjhic}cec ulechi.rlic}ce* Hdltmtc he}phi`

CUUJ 4822.2273 Elrstcaf}Wlv Rfcilulrfch` ]lh}` mt`r}ptci` t`z`twh}` 84

m` ih }tcpnwcth}pi Ilek`) D`tk`i`s) Fpn` ih `nrctcunpi u`elipipc hi VWCCC.i`h)eh u u` m`zwli}` nhc hi`u j u`elipi hi VV.i`h) mcwczjmp.u` j mlp thnptc?}`ltch icndho`ilt cm`hi` ep Qc}}a`ju}`cj) Tpuu`ii c Hs`t) eht` ndcj hjhiczhilace ep `nrctcunpi) et`jm rlzc}cwcunpi ilace) c }`ltch icndhopipc ldcjpc})eht` wh ep}h hjhiczh }p}ptlt rtlrlzcccilt r`j}tp h u}hdcic u`njcgcehchelju}c}p`jcilt ilt* O* I* Hpu}cj h et`h} elhih gcilulgce h icndhopipc ldcjpc} m`ih Lvgltm ep}jm mcg`t`jh j}t` gltn`i` ilepcljht` c cilepcljht`* R` he``hcicjc` hjhic}ce) R* G* U}thqulj c N* Mpnn`}} u` wlt leprh m` hjhicz`) t`g`tcj`icjawcu}ce`) u` wh m`zwli}h e`te`}ht`h t`ihc`c cj}`i`e}.icndho* U.hp rpu rtldi`n`hi` hjhicz`c rtlrlzcccilt mcj gcilulgch nlthi`c c `}ce* O* L* Ptnulj `u}` `mc}ltpiipettcilt ipc Hpu}cj c pjpi mcj cu}ltcecc gcilulgc`c hjhic}ce`*

Rlzc}cwcunpi ilace je`hte u m`zwli}` c u ucu}`nh}cz`z` `nrctcunpim` }cr Fpn` ep hop}ltpi n`}lm`ilt nlm`tj` ilacel.nh}`nh}ce`* H glu}m`zwli}h} m` D* Tpuu`ii c I* Qc}}a`ju}`cj* Uhtecjh gcilulgc`c `u}` m` h `ipecmhmcg`t`jh mcj}t` rtlrlzccci` ghe}phi` c e`i` icruc}` m` u`ju ru`pmlrtlrlzccci`n`}hgczcecc) `}cecc) `u}`}cecc) `vrt`ucc hi` h}c}pmcjcilt rtlrlzccljhi`* @u}` hmncurtcjecrcpi w`tcgcehdcic}cc) eht` upucj` e u`njcgcehch rtlrlzcc`c `u}` mh} m`ldu`twhcci` c `vr`tcn`j}`i` eht` l }`u}`hz* jhcj}`h j}t`dtcilt m`urt` hm`wtc ghiuc}h}` u` e`t` rpu j}t`dht`h eht` upj} rtlrlzccci` ep u`njcgcehcc c eht`jp*

M* D*? 5* Eljucm`thc e nhjc`th hjhic}ce m` h rthe}ceh gcilulgch`u}` nhc rl}tcwc} r`j}tp hjpnc}` mcuecricj` gcilulgce`) uhp he`hu}h rlh}`gc hriceh} ep he``hc jmt`r}ct` j }lh}` mcuecricj`i`